Open Letter from Gaza Academics

POSTED BY JENNIFER RUTH

This open letter to the world from Gaza academics and university administrators was published yesterday by Al Jazeera here. On May 6, Israel’s cabinet voted to ban Al Jazeera and shut down its local offices. Among the many things American academics might do in response to help, one would be to listen to Professor Daniel Segal when he calls for the AAUP’s antiboycott position to be reexamined.

We have come together as Palestinian academics and staff of Gaza universities to affirm our existence, the existence of our colleagues and our students, and the insistence on our future, in the face of all current attempts to erase us.

The Israeli occupation forces have demolished our buildings but our universities live on. We reaffirm our collective determination to remain on our land and to resume teaching, study, and research in Gaza, at our own Palestinian universities, at the earliest opportunity.

We call upon our friends and colleagues around the world to resist the ongoing campaign of scholasticide in occupied Palestine, to work alongside us in rebuilding our demolished universities, and to refuse all plans seeking to bypass, erase, or weaken the integrity of our academic institutions. The future of our young people in Gaza depends upon us, and our ability to remain on our land in order to continue to serve the coming generations of our people.

We issue this call from beneath the bombs of the occupation forces across occupied Gaza, in the refugee camps of Rafah, and from the sites of temporary new exile in Egypt and other host countries. We are disseminating it as the Israeli occupation continues to wage its genocidal campaign against our people daily, in its attempt to eliminate every aspect of our collective and individual life.

Our families, colleagues, and students are being assassinated, while we have once again been rendered homeless, reliving the experiences of our parents and grandparents during the massacres and mass expulsions by Zionist armed forces in 1947 and 1948.

Our civic infrastructure – universities, schools, hospitals, libraries, museums and cultural centres – built by generations of our people, lies in ruins from this deliberate continuous Nakba. The deliberate targeting of our educational infrastructure is a blatant attempt to render Gaza uninhabitable and erode the intellectual and cultural fabric of our society. However, we refuse to allow such acts to extinguish the flame of knowledge and resilience that burns within us.

Allies of the Israeli occupation in the United States and United Kingdom are opening yet another scholasticide front through promoting alleged reconstruction schemes that seek to eliminate the possibility of independent Palestinian educational life in Gaza. We reject all such schemes and urge our colleagues to refuse any complicity in them. We also urge all universities and colleagues worldwide to coordinate any academic aid efforts directly with our universities.

We extend our heartfelt appreciation to the national and international institutions that have stood in solidarity with us, providing support and assistance during these challenging times. However, we stress the importance of coordinating these efforts to effectively reopen Palestinian universities in Gaza.

We emphasize the urgent need to reoperate Gaza’s education institutions, not merely to support current students, but to ensure the long-term resilience and sustainability of our higher education system. Education is not just a means of imparting knowledge; it is a vital pillar of our existence and a beacon of hope for the Palestinian people.

Accordingly, it is essential to formulate a long-term strategy for rehabilitating the infrastructure and rebuilding the entire facilities of the universities. However, such endeavors require considerable time and substantial funding, posing a risk to the ability of academic institutions to sustain operations, potentially leading to the loss of staff, students, and the capacity to reoperate.

Given the current circumstances, it is imperative to swiftly transition to online teaching to mitigate the disruption caused by the destruction of physical infrastructure. This transition necessitates comprehensive support to cover operational costs, including the salaries of academic staff.

Student fees, the main source of income for universities, have collapsed since the start of the genocide. The lack of income has left staff without salaries, pushing many of them to search for external opportunities.

Beyond striking at the livelihoods of university faculty and staff, this financial strain caused by the deliberate campaign of scholasticide poses an existential threat to the future of the universities themselves.

Thus, urgent measures must be taken to address the financial crisis now faced by academic institutions, to ensure their very survival. We call upon all concerned parties to immediately coordinate their efforts in support of this critical objective.

The rebuilding of Gaza’s academic institutions is not just a matter of education; it is a testament to our resilience, determination, and unwavering commitment to securing a future for generations to come.

The fate of higher education in Gaza belongs to the universities in Gaza, their faculty, staff, and students and to the Palestinian people as a whole. We appreciate the efforts of peoples and citizens around the world to bring an end to this ongoing genocide.

We call upon our colleagues in the homeland and internationally to support our steadfast attempts to defend and preserve our universities for the sake of the future of our people, and our ability to remain on our Palestinian land in Gaza. We built these universities from tents. And from tents, with the support of our friends, we will rebuild them once again.

Signatories:

Dr Kamalain Shaath, Vice Chairman of the Board of Trustees, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Prof Omar Milad, President of Al Azhar University Gaza, Al Azhar University Gaza, Dr Mohamed Reyad Zughbur, Dean of the Faculty of Medicine, Al Azhar University Gaza, Dr Nasser Abu Alatta, Dean of Students Affairs, Al Aqsa University, Dr Akram Mohammed Radwan, Dean of Admission, Registration, and Student Affairs, University College of Applied Sciences – Gaza, Dr Atta Abu Hany, Dean of Faculty of Science, Al Azhar University Gaza, Prof Hamdi Shhadeh Zourb, Dean of the Faculty of Economics and Administrative Sciences, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Dr Ahmed Abu Shaban, Dean of the Faculty of Agriculture and Veterinary Medicine, Al Azhar University Gaza, Dr Ahmed A Najim, Dean of Admission and Registration, Al Azhar University Gaza, Dr Noha A Nijim, Dean of Economics and Administrative Science Faculty, Al Azhar University Gaza, Prof Hatem Ali Al-Aidi, Dean of Planning and Quality, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Dr Ihab A Naser Dean of Faculty of Applied Medical Sciences, Al Azhar University Gaza
Eng Amani Al-Mqadama, Head of the International Relations, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Dr Mohammed R AlBaba, Dean of Faculty of Dentistry, Al Azhar University Gaza, Dr Rami Wishah , Dean of the Faculty of Law, Al Azhar University Gaza
Prof Basim Mohammad Ayesh, Head of MSc Programme Committee and Professor of Molecular Genetics, Al Aqsa University, Prof Hassan Asour, Dean of Scientific Research, Al Azhar University Gaza, Khaled Ismail Shahada Tabish, Head of Salaries Department, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Prof Mazen Sabbah, Dean of Faculty of Sharia, Al Azhar University Gaza
Dr Ashraf J Shaqalaih, Head of Laboratory Medicine Dept, Al Azhar University Gaza, Dr Mahmoud El Ajouz, Head of Food Analysis Center and Lecturer at the Faculty of Agriculture, Al Azhar University Gaza, Dr Mazen AbuQamar, Head of Nursing Department, Al Azhar University Gaza, Eng Abed Elnaser Mustafa Abu Assi, Head of Engineering Office, Al Azhar University Gaza, Dr Ahmed Rezk Al-Wawi, Vice President of the Islamic University Workers’ Union, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Shareef El Buhaisi, Head of Administration Office at the Faculty of Applied Medical Sciences, Al Azhar University Gaza, Dr Saeb Hussein Al-Owaini, Director of Employees, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Dr Mai Ramadan, Director of the Drug and Toxicology Analysis Centre, Al Azhar University Gaza, Dr Mohammed S M Kuhail, Director of Libraries, Al Azhar University Gaza, Emad Ahmed Ismail Al-Nounou, Director, Technical Department, Al Azhar University Gaza, Ismail Abdul Rahman Abu Sukhaila, Director Engineering Office, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Osama R Shawwa, Director of Administrative Office in the Department of Political Sciences, Al Azhar University Gaza, Adnan A S El-Ajrami, Director of Administrative Office at the Faculty of Medicine, Al Azhar University Gaza
Hashem Mahmoud Kassab, Director of Public Relations and Media Department, Al Azhar University Gaza, Mazen Hilles, Director of Administration of Diploma Programme, Al Azhar University Gaza, Adel Mansour Suleiman Al-Louh , Services Manager, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Hammam Al-Nabahen, Director of IT Services, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Maher Haron Ereif, Audit Department Assistant Director, Al Azhar University Gaza, Khalid Solayman Alsayed, Information Technology Administrator, Al Azhar University Gaza, Dr Amani H Abujarad, Assistant Professor of Applied Linguistics Department of English, Al Azhar University Gaza
Dr Ayman Shaheen, Assistant Professor in Political Sciences, Al Azhar University Gaza, Prof Alaa Mustafa Al-Halees, Faculty of Information Technology, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Prof Basil Hamed, Faculty of Engineering, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG)
Dr Mohamed Elhindy, Assistant Professor in Veterinary Medicine, Al Azhar University Gaza, Prof Bassam Ahmed Abu Zaher, Faculty of Science, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Prof Fakhr Abo Awad, Faculty of Science – Department of Chemistry, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Prof Saher Al Waleed, Professor of Law, Al Azhar University Gaza, Prof Kamal Ahmed Ghneim, Faculty of Arts, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Prof Khadir Tawfiq Khadir, Department of English Language – Faculty of Arts, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Dr Marwan Saleem El-Agha, Assistant Professor of Business Administration, Al Azhar University Gaza, Dr Mona Jehad Wadi, Assistant Professor of microbiology, Al Azhar University Gaza, Dr Mohammed Faek Aziz, Deanship of Quality and Development, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Dr Muhammed Abu Mattar, Associate Professor in Law, Al Azhar University Gaza, Prof Abdul Fattah Nazmi Hassan Abdel Rabbo, Faculty of Science, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Dr Saher Al Waleed, Professor of Law, Al Azhar University Gaza, Dr Sari El Sahhar, Assistant Professor in Plant Protection, Al Azhar University Gaza, Dr Nidal Jamal Masoud Jarada, Law, University College of Applied Sciences – Gaza, Dr Sherin H Aldani, Assistant Professor in Social Sciences, Al Azhar University Gaza, Dr Wael Mousa, Assistant Professor in Food Technology, Al Azhar University Gaza, Prof Mohamed I H Migdad, Faculty of Economics and Administrative Sciences, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Prof Alaa Mustafa Al-Halees, Faculty of Information Technology, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Prof Usama Hashem Hamed Hegazy, Professor of Applied Mathematics, Al Azhar University Gaza, Prof Basil Hamed, Faculty of Engineering, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Prof Tawfik Musa Allouh, Professor of Arabic Literature, Al Azhar University Gaza, Prof Bassam Ahmed Abu Zaher, Faculty of Science, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Prof Zaki S Safi, Professor of Chemistry, Al Azhar University Gaza, Prof Fakhr Abo Awad, Faculty of Science – Department of Chemistry, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Prof Kamal Ahmed Ghneim, Faculty of Arts, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Prof Khadir Tawfiq Khadir, Department of English Language – Faculty of Arts, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Prof Khaled Hussein Hamdan, Faculty of Fundamentals of Religion, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG)
Prof Ata Hasan Ismail Darwish, Professor of Science Education and Curriculum, Al Azhar University Gaza, Prof Hazem Falah Sakeek, Professor of Physics, Al Azhar University Gaza, Prof Mohammed Abdel Aati, Department of Electrical Engineering and Intelligent Systems, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Prof Nader Jawad Al-Nimra, Faculty of Engineering, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Prof Nasir Sobhy Abu Foul, Professor of Food Technology, Al Azhar University Gaza, Dr Rawand Sami Abu Nahla, Lecturer at Faculty of Dentistry, Al Azhar University Gaza, Prof Hussein M. H. Alhendawi, Professor of Organic Chemistry, Al Azhar University Gaza, Prof Ihab S. S. Zaqout, Professor in Computer Science, Al Azhar University Gaza, Dr Rushdy A S Wady, Faculty of Economics and Administrative Sciences, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Dr Abed El-Raziq A Salama, Assistant Professor in Food Technology, Al Azhar University Gaza, Dr Ahmed Aabed, Admin Assistant in Administrative and Financial Affairs Office, Al Azhar University Gaza, Dr Ahmed Mesmeh, Faculty of Sharia and Law, Al Azhar University Gaza, Dr Emad Khalil Abu Alkhair Masoud, Associate professor of microbiology, Al Azhar University Gaza, Dr Alaa Issa Mohammed Saleh, Lecturer at the faculty of Dentistry, Al Azhar University Gaza, Dr Ali Al-Jariri, Continuing Education Department, Al Quds Open University
Dr Arwa Eid Ashour, Faculty of Science, Department of Mathematics, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Dr Hala Zakaria Alagha, Assistant Professor in Clinical Pharmacy, Al Azhar University Gaza, Prof Marwan Khazinda, Professor of Mathematics, Al Azhar University Gaza, Prof Moamin Alhanjouri, Associate Professor in Statistics, Al Azhar University Gaza, Prof Sameer Mostafa Abumdallala, Professor of Economics, Al Azhar University Gaza, Dr Bilal Al-Dabbour, Faculty of Medicine, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Dr Nabil Kamel Mohammed Dukhan, Faculty of Education – Department of Psychology, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Dr Jamal Mohamed Alshareef, Assistant Professor, Linguistics Department of English, Al Azhar University Gaza
Dr Sadiq Ahmed Mohammed Abdel Aal, Faculty of Engineering, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG)
Dr Khaled Abushab, Associate Professor in Applied Medical Sciences, Al Azhar University Gaza
Dr Abed El-Raziq A Salama, Assistant Professor in Food Technology, Al Azhar University Gaz
Dr Emad Khalil Abu Alkhair Masoud, Associate Professor of Microbiology, Al Azhar University Gaza
Dr Hala Zakaria Alagha, Assistant Professor in Clinical Pharmacy, Al Azhar University Gaza
Dr Jamal Mohamed Alshareef, Assistant Professor, Linguistics Department of English, Al Azhar University Gaza
Dr Khaled Abushab, Associate Professor in Applied Medical Sciences, Al Azhar University Gaza
Dr Suheir Ammar, Faculty of Engineering, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG)
Dr Waseem Bahjat Mushtaha, Associate Professor in Dental Medicine, Al Azhar University Gaza
Prof Ali Abu Zaid, Professor of Statistics, Al Azhar University Gaza
Dr Zahir Mahmoud Khalil Nassar, Faculty of Science, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG)
Abdul Hamid Mustafa Said Mortaja, Faculty of Arts, Department of Arabic Language, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG)
Abdul Rahman Salman Nasr Al-Daya, Associate Professor at the Faculty of Sharia and Law, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG)
Ayman Salah Khalil Abumayla, Officer – Student Affairs Department, Al Azhar University Gaza
Abdullah Ahmed Al-Sawarqa, Library, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG)
Ashraf Ahmed Mohammed Abu Mughisib, Faculty of Science, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG)
Mohammed Abdul Fattah Abdel Rabbo, Deanship of Engineering and Information Systems, University College of Applied Sciences – Gaza, Basheer Ismail Hamed Hammo, Faculty of Fundamentals of Religion, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG)
Bssam Fadel Nssar, Faculty of Engineering, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG)
Eng Mohammed Awni Abushaban, Teaching Assistant IT Department, Al Azhar University Gaza
Etemad Mohammed Abdul Aziz Al-Attar, Faculty of Science, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG)
Fahd Ghassan Abdullah Al-Khatib, Engineering Office, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG)
Ibrahim K I Albozom, Administrative Officer Faculty of Arts, Al Azhar University Gaza
Abdullah Ahmed Anaqlah, Faculty of Information Technology, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG)
Ahmed Abdelrahman Abu Saloom, Radiologist at the College of Dentistry, Al Azhar University Gaza
Feryal Ali Mahmoud Farhat, Administrator, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Fifi Al-Zard, Campus Services, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Manar Y Abuamara, Secretary, Al Azhar University Gaza, Hani Rubhi Abdel Aal, Graduate Studies, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG)
Ahmed Abdul Raouf Al-Mabhouh, Faculty of Science, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Ahmed Adnan Al-Qazzaz, Faculty of Information Technology, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Sfadi Salim Abu Amra, Supporting Services Department, Al Azhar University Gaza, Hassan Ahmed Hassan Al-Nabih, Department of English Language – Faculty of Arts, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Hassan Nasr, Information Technology, University College of Applied Sciences – Gaza
Hatem Barhoom, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Tamer Musallam, Lecturer in Business Diploma Programme, Al Azhar University Gaza, Ahmed Adnan Mahmoud Mattar, Information Technology, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Ahmed Jaber Mahmoud Al-Omsey, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Ahmed Khalil Ibrahim Qadoura, Administrator, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG) Hussein Al-Jadaily, Faculty of Nursing, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Ibrahim Issa Ibrahim Seidem, Faculty of Fundamentals of Religion, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG)
Ezia Abu Zaida, Secretary, Al Azhar University Gaza, Khaled Mutlaq Issa, Faculty of Engineering, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Khalil Mohammed Said Hassan Abu Kuweik, Faculty of Economics and Administrative Sciences, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG)
Ibraheem Almasharawi, Instructor at the Faculty of Agriculture and Veterinary Medicine, Al Azhar University Gaza
Maher Jaber Mahmoud Shaqlieh, Information Technology Affairs, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Mahmoud Abdul Rahman Mousa Asraf, Department of English Language, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Ahmed Mohammed Said Abu Safi, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Ahmed Omar Ismail Al-Dahdouh, Faculty of Information Technology, University College of Applied Sciences – Gaza, Ahmed Salman Ali Abu Amra, Faculty of Sharia and Law, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Ahmed Saqer, Faculty of Science, Department of Mathematics, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Ahmed Younes Abu Labda, Personnel Affairs, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Alaa Fathi Salim Abu Ajwa, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Mahmoud Said Mohammed Al- Damouni, Central Library, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Ghasasn Alswairki, Adminstration Officer at Faculty of Pharmacy, Al Azhar University Gaza, Mahmoud Shukri Sarhan, Faculty of Education, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Mahmoud Youssef Mohammed Al- Shoubaki, Faculty of Fundamentals of Religion, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Majdi Said Aqel, Faculty of Education, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG)
Muahmmed Abu Aouda, Security Department, Al Azhar University Gaza, Majed Hania, Faculty of Science, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Majed Mohammed Ibrahim Al-Naami, Faculty of Literature, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Mamoun Abdul Aziz Ahmed Salha, Information Technology, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Emad Ali Ahmed Abdel Rabbo, Administrator, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Imad Alwaheidi Lecturer in Livestock Production Al Azhar University Gaza., Manar Mustafa Al-Maghari, Medical Department, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG)Mohammed Bassam Mohammed Al- Kurd, Campus Services, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG)Marwa Rouhi Abu Jalaleh, Information Technology Department, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Yousif Altaban, Security Department, Al Azhar University Gaza, Hala Muti Mahmoud Abu Naqeera, Student Affairs, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Marwan Ismail Abdul Rahman Hamad, Faculty of Education, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Mohammad Hussein Kraizem, Health Sciences, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Mohammed AlAshi, Faculty of Economics and Administrative Sciences, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Mohammed Hassan Al-Sar, Faculty of Engineering, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Mohammed Ibrahim Khidr Al-Gomasy, Faculty of Education, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Mohammed Juma Al-Ghoul, Faculty of Sharia and Law, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Mohammed Khalil Ayesh, Information Technology, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Faiz Ahmed Ali Hales, Computer Maintenance Department, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Mohammed Taha Mohammed Abu Qadama, Administrator, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Yousef Fahmy Krayem, Lab Technician at Faculty of Agriculture and Veterinary Medicine, Al Azhar University Gaza, Nabhan Salem Abu Jamous, Department of Supplies and Purchases, Head of Storage Section, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Nihad Mohammed Sheikh Khalil, Faculty of Arts – Department of History, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Tamer Nazeer Nassar Madi, Faculty of Information Technology, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Rami Othman Mohammed Hassan Skik, Faculty of Information Technology, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Salah Hassan Radwan, Information Technology, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Salem Abushawarib, Faculty of Economics and Administrative Sciences, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Salem Jameel Bakir Al-Sazaji, Faculty of Information Technology, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Abed Alraouf S Almasharawi, Administrative Officer in the Library, Al Azhar University Gaza, Samah Al-Samoni, Public Relations, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Wafa Farhan Ismail Ubaid, Faculty of Nursing, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Tawfiq Sufian Tawfiq Harzallah, Admission and Registration Department, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Walid Zuheir Aidi Abu Shaaban, Finance and Auditing Department, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Yasser Zaidan Salem Al-Nahal, Faculty of Science, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), Youssef Sobhi Abdel Nabi Al-Rantissi, Computer Technician, Islamic University of Gaza (IUG)

9 thoughts on “Open Letter from Gaza Academics

  1. “Allies of the Israeli occupation in the United States and United Kingdom are opening yet another scholasticide front through promoting alleged reconstruction schemes that seek to eliminate the possibility of independent Palestinian educational life in Gaza.” This is a serious, yet extremely vague allegation. I would like to learn more about such proposals. Who has initiated them? What kind of support have they gathered? What are their specifics? Can anyone provide more information or direct us to other sources?

  2. There are no real universities in Gaza. These are all explicitly Islamist institutions run by Hamas and they have served as military sites for Hamas fighters. Shame on you for providing this active support for the fascist butchers and their ideological promoters.

    • At a moment when all universities in Gazan have been destroyed by a brutal assault from an occupying power (the Israeli state), to denigrate those universities is, frankly, obscene, even hateful. Let us all note that Mr. Nadel offers no support for his attacks on the reputation of the now destroyed universities. In point of fact, Gaza had serious universities where our colleagues in Gaza worked hard and seriously and successfully to educate their students. There is no evidence that Mr. Nadel has direct or even indirect knowledge of these universities, their faculty, or their graduates. It’s all just anti-Palestinian hate and racism, with no evidence or reasoned argument. In case any reader jumps to the wrong conclusion, I want to affirm that Mr. Nadel’s expression of hate is protected speech and I am not advocating removing his comment or anything of the sort; I do, however, feel physically ill having read his comments in a context where I feel grief and rage for the ongoing genocide that Mr. Nadel seems dedicated to rationalizing.

    • “No real universities…”
      “No real hospitals…”
      “No real civilians…”
      .
      .
      “No real humans…”

  3. It seems clear that Israel deliberately targeted and physically destroyed all of Gaza’s universities in the first few months after the October 7 Hamas attack. But many of the students and faculty of these universities are still alive and want to resume their academic work. It may seem too mild to call the bombing of academic buildings a violation of academic freedom, but that’s what it is, in a form so extreme it’s hard to acknowledge and process what’s going on. I think the AAUP should condemn this.

    • The militarization of these so called universities is well documented. Hamas turned them into legitimate military targets and that’s what should outrage American academics and not the legitimate targeting of these military sites in wartime.

      • Stan Nadel repeats standard Israeli propaganda, which has no factual basis and is contradicted by available evidence. In “Genocide in Gaza,” human rights experts report: “Israel has destroyed every university in Gaza, blowing up the last of Gaza’s universities on January 17, 2024. Videos recorded by Israeli forces showed the destruction of Israa University with a controlled detonation of explosives. The Israeli military reportedly was using the building for 70 days as a military base and an ad hoc detention facility for interrogating Palestinian detainees.” (p. 56, citations omitted).

        The attacks are not limited to higher education: “Israel’s systematic attacks on the education system have nearly eliminated access to education in Gaza. UN independent human rights experts reported in April 2024 that 80 percent of Gaza’s schools had been damaged or destroyed…. Commissioner-General of UNRWA Phillipe Lazzarini warned that the systematic damage to the Gazan education system would result in a “lost generation” of Gaza’s youth.” (pp. 55-56, citations omitted.)

        All of this is part of a much larger picture of cultural, biological, and physical destruction that was announced in advance by Israeli leaders, as documented in this report. For more, you can find a summary and download the full report, including detailed citations, at this link:
        https://www.humanrightsnetwork.org/genocide-in-gaza

Your comments are welcome, but please be considerate about the tone, length, and frequency of your comments in order to avoid dominating the conversation on the blog or discouraging others from joining the conversation. They must be relevant to the topic at hand and must not contain advertisements, degrade others, use ad hominem attacks, or violate laws or considerations of privacy. We encourage the use of your real name, but do not prohibit pseudonyms as long as you don’t impersonate a real person. Repeat violators of the commenting policy may be blocked from further commenting.