No, He’s Not Just Incompetent

BY HANK REICHMAN Given the case’s high importance, a U.S. District Court judge says he hopes to issue an order by January 24 on a suit filed by a group of University of Florida professors to invalidate the school’s conflict of interest policy as an unconstitutional infringement on freedom of speech.  “This is on the…

debate

Debating the Emory Law Journal Controversy

BY JOHN K. WILSON On Wednesday, the Chronicle of Higher Education’s Review posted dueling essays by Northwestern law professor Andrew Koppelman and me (reposted from this blog) about the controversy over the Emory Law Journal. Prof. Koppleman and I decided to continue the discussion, and below is our back-and-forth exchange. John K. Wilson: You wrote…

Newfield on Newsom

BY HANK REICHMAN The indispensable Chris Newfield has a new post up at his blog Remaking the University, “Newsom’s *Big Funding* Budget for UC and CSU is Flat.”  In it he picks apart the false promises in California governor Gavin Newsom’s initial budget proposal for higher education, although the focus is mostly on the University…

A Case of “Whataboutism”

BY HANK REICHMAN In a recent zoom meeting I had occasion to meet Monica Casper, dean of the College of Arts and Letters at San Diego State University.  Dean Casper mentioned that she had recently been the target of online harassment and controversy for some tweets she had posted.  Curious, I looked into the case…

Screenshot of John Wilson's article

The Self-Censorship Problem

BY JOHN K. WILSON Yesterday, I published an opinion essay at Inside Higher Ed titled, “The Inevitable Problem of Self-Censorship.” I argue that surveys showing that a majority of college students report self-censorship are not meaningful ways to understand repression on campus because everyone self-censors to some degree. These surveys are also easy to manipulate.…

Per Aspera ad Astra

BY HANK REICHMAN Ohio State University professor emeritus Harvey Graff, who occasionally posts to this blog, has a smart and entertaining piece today in the Washington Monthly on “The Banality of University Slogans.”  You know, the kind of mindless “branding” pablum like, “Here, everything is possible!”  It brought to mind the time when my university,…

Emory University School of Law

In Defense of the Emory Law Journal

BY JOHN K. WILSON This week, there was what Jonathan Turley called a “major controversy brewing over free speech and censorship at Emory Law Journal.” Robert George argued, “It’s hard to think of a stupider, more self-defeating idea than imposing political litmus tests on articles submitted to major law reviews. But that’s what the Emory…

a row of colorful crayons on a white surface recedes diagonally into the background

Learning from UT Austin about Academic Freedom and Community Education

BY Z. W. TAYLOR, PAT SOMERS, AND JOSH CHILDS  The AAUP outlines a four-pronged definition of academic freedom, although it is not codified by any specific case law or statute. Dozens of educational organizations—including the American Psychological Association, the Association for the Study of Higher Education, and the National Education Association, among many others—have endorsed…