The midterm elections certainly should be characterized as a referendum on President Trump. With both the Senate and House now controlled by Democrats by significant margins, his agenda attacking higher education may be stalled. And with the victories won by the AAUP and its allies in court, you may well think any broader Republican agenda is as lame as Trump.
But this broader agenda has influence and leverage due to both GOP wins at the state level and the president’s executive authority. Even if one applauds the flips of Texas and Georgia state governments, higher education changes may take years as seats on boards of regents open up. And let’s remember: The 2028 presidential campaign started the moment races were called.
Assuming the forces attacking higher education will continue, it’s important to pay attention to their playbook. Project 2025 is halfway complete. So, what’s next? This brings me to the recent book Higher Education in America: It’s Worse Than You Think, an edited collection of diagnoses and reforms organized by the Heritage Foundation. The contributors many of you might recognize: Christopher Rufo offers an introduction; Larry Arnn, former chair of Trump’s 1776 Commission, offers a foreword; and a slew of lesser-known conservatives tackle topics such as the economic model, bureaucracy, and “leftist dominance” of higher education.
The book offers the clearest description for what could be coming if the forces attacking higher ed continue to thrive. Am I recommending you read it? Yes. Am I recommending you buy it? No. And, full disclosure, I did not read every word, only those chapters that interested me. And any quotes below come from chapters I actually read.
Two goals mentioned by one contributor should frame your understanding of this movement: “The only way to break the ideological homogeneity of higher education is to starve existing universities of taxpayers and donor dollars while diverting new resources toward the establishment of competing universities that offer different perspectives.”
That starving could come by way of state lawmakers. Kevin Roberts, the Heritage Foundation president, calls for such lawmakers to “redirect the culture of their institutions” by declining all federal spending entirely from loans to grants (if you are wondering on the latter, Roberts suggests private companies will fill the void). And while it may seem extreme, I am willing to bet there are a few state lawmakers willing to consider it.
Accreditation is the other method of starvation. Reform in that area for these partisan actors is not merely satisfied by the creation of the Commission for Public Higher Education and downstream effects on other accreditors, as the chapter’s authors suggest “any business or institution” should be able to become a recognized accreditor. Imagine, then, hospitals accrediting a school’s nursing program, or a Fortune 500 company accrediting the business program.
The other way to starve disciplines and departments is by creating “a dissident university within the existing university,” aka civics institutes, who then not only compete for students but have hiring freedom outside traditional faculty oversight—all for the goal of “competitive coexistence.” This leads to the ironic endorsement by another contributor of “cluster hires” for conservatives, after claiming this method is “more likely to recruit scholar-activists” on the progressive side of political spectrum.
Then there are the concepts of institutional neutrality and viewpoint diversity, which the book makes clear to denote as empty placeholders covering darker agendas. Rufo dispenses with the first fig leaf when he suggests “neutrality gives no sense of direction and inquiry is not an end in itself,” and the latter is undercut by Patrick Deneen, political science professor at Notre Dame, who argues the current definitions of viewpoint diversity used by conservatives are “extremely constrained.” Instead of that lukewarm fad, Deneen proposes “a conservative university ideal that would help to shift the nation as a whole in a more conservative direction.”
That ideal comes in the form of a most daring suggestion: the creation of a “premier academy” to train “nationalist and America-first graduates of America’s colleges and universities” as they find their way to Washington, DC, for work in government or think tanks, a (taxpayer funded?) grad school for Trumpism (or whatever ideology akin to that which comes next).
The book is filled with other broad claims and general diagnoses that surely need more engagement than I can offer on this blog. And while the tone isn’t scholarly, consider the audience for the hefty hardback priced at $32.99. The chapters are short—five to eight pages written to be read by people not in higher education—and the lawmakers called to act and other stakeholders who have power over higher education likely in “red” states are the most obvious audience. The “you” in the subtitle clearly aims at people who already think it’s bad out there and bad for specific ideological reasons—the people who would start and fund those civics institutes.
These are the same people many of us must engage with if we are to reach our goals for higher education. Maybe indeed there are readers of this blog or broader AAUP members who want more civics institutes. In Texas, Georgia, and other southern states, the organizing of faculty must include advocating to those people, who need to understand the long-term effects of the proposals in this book. If implemented, they will squeeze enrollments, limit opportunity, and turn many off from the very civic lessons they intend to teach.
And our playbook must be as visible so we can argue for the common good.
Matthew Boedy is the president of the Georgia AAUP state conference.




Project 2025 and Heritage are part of the anti-civil rights movement to which I devoted a 2025 book. The first two years of the Trump administration have been in the works since at least 1954, when the backlash against Brown v Education that has morphed into the anti-DEI movement (where much of the work of universities and various government agencies is defined as DEI began.