BY ALAN SINGER
In today’s high-tech world, email and the internet are fundamental to the exchange of ideas and freedom of expression. Threats to cut off faculty and student access are threats to academic freedom and democracy.
The University of Kentucky recently distributed to faculty a “draft” policy for the use of university technology hardware, software, and systems including email and Wi-Fi that would prohibit “engaging in substantial personal communications” and “political activity of any type.” Students, faculty, and staff would also be banned from soliciting contributions, promoting commercial products, operating a personal or private business, and posting to nonuniversity social media. Punishment for failure to adhere to these restrictions would include “termination of access” or unstated disciplinary action. Definitions are so broad that faculty members could be brought up on charges if they use their office computers to post a comment on a New York Times article, engage in any sort of online political discussion, explain who and why they are voting for someone, take a stand on an academic debate in their field, contact a union representative, search for information on a controversial topic, or share articles on what administrators deem to be “political” subjects with students in their classes. By the way, these are all things that I do as a faculty member.
The University of Kentucky proposal includes a threat to monitor email use to ensure students and faculty do not violate the directive. “Authorized users do not have an expectation of privacy for the data and content of the university-owned computer and software assigned to them.” UK claimed it has the right to “access the content or copy the content of such a computer at any time for any reason. The university may also demand the return of the university-owned computer and software at any time for any reason.”
A number of faculty are protesting UK’s claim that it has the right to view all email activity conducted on university equipment and using its network as a violation of corporate nondisclosure agreements and government grant requirements for sensitive projects, especially military-related research.
The university is currently being sued by Ramsi Woodcock, a law professor who was barred from teaching and from the law school campus for arguing that Israel’s actions in Gaza constitute genocide. Woodcock believes the purpose of the proposed policy is “to make it even easier for it to carry out such blatantly unconstitutional conduct. It’s as if, for the current administration of the university, the First Amendment had been adopted on Mars rather than in the United States of America.” Kentucky Attorney General Russell Coleman filed a legal brief supporting the university; it argued that public universities should have more control over what their employees say. He is supported by Republican attorneys general in at least thirteen states.
In response to the university issuing a call for comments on the proposed restrictive tech policy, Woodstock proposes an alternative policy that is endorsed by the University of Kentucky AAUP chapter. His proposal cites policy statements at other universities and calls on Kentucky to respect “privacy as a foundation of academic freedom” and “incidental personal use as an accepted and appropriate benefit” and to recognize scholarly teaching and research on politics as appropriate and desirable.” It would also mandate prior “consent before anyone examines a user’s files.” Many of Woodstock’s proposals are drawn from use-of-tech guidelines at other universities.
The ACLU has challenged policies like those proposed by UK as suppression of free speech at least since 1996 when Princeton University notified students that they could not “participate in, or intervene in, any political campaign on behalf of any candidate for public office” because use of university technology could threaten the university’s tax-exempt status. After pressure from students and the ACLU, Princeton withdrew the restriction.
In response to the Kentucky draft proposal, legal counsel for the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression stated, “Tax-exempt institutions can’t themselves engage in political activity, but IRS guidance makes clear this doesn’t mean a student can’t engage in political activity using that college’s resources, so long as students get equal access to those resources, and the student’s speech doesn’t imply the university actually endorsed that political activity.”
Other universities have implemented less broad and restrictive limits on university computer services, but these are also problematic. The City University of New York restricts use of its computer and network resources to official duties or coursework; however, it insists that its policies “support the free exchange of ideas among members of the CUNY community and between the CUNY community and other communities, while recognizing the responsibilities and limitations associated with such exchange.” It is unclear how the policy can both “support the free exchange of ideas” and limit computer use to “official duties.”
Stony Brook University “reserves the right to examine, without user consent, material stored on or transmitted through its IT systems if there is reason to believe that the standards for responsible use in this policy are being violated.” The university reserves the right to monitor student and faculty activity, remove content or disable web sites, and disable accounts. Stony Brook also notes, “Persons who become aware of credible suspected violations of this policy should report them to: stonybrook.ethicspoint.com.” I find these guidelines particularly disturbing because in May 2024, Stony Brook administrators had campus, local, and state police break up an encampment protesting against Israel’s war on Gaza. Protesters were arrested, and cell phones were confiscated. Under Stony Brook’s tech guidelines, anyone who supported or even reported on the protests using the university IT systems was subject to being banned from the system.
Alan Singer is director of social studies secondary education at Hofstra University.



Use of company computers to engage in activity that does not reflect the university should be prohibited. If you want the freedom to do otherwise, you must pay for that freedom. Use your own laptop and pay for hotspot usage.