Black background with speech bubbles of various sizes drawn with white chalk

A Modest Defense of Viewpoint Diversity

BY DALE E. MILLER In “Seven Theses Against Viewpoint Diversity,” Professor Lisa Siraganian throws down a gauntlet. After offering “seven theses against viewpoint diversity in any of its guises,” she writes that “if viewpoint diversity means committing oneself to a robust debate about truth and values, then the movement should be open to responding to…

Two hands hold up a blank cardboard sign with blue sky in the background

Building the Protest-Free University

BY MICHAEL SCHWALBE Most Americans are accustomed to authoritarianism by virtue of their daily experiences in the workplace. Managers make, interpret, and enforce the rules by which private companies operate; they say what goes, and they can use force to impose their will. Employees who resist can be disciplined or fired, often without due process…

A small plant growing from a barren landscape

What Retrenchment Taught Me About Staying

BY RACHEL BOUVIER Act I: Collateral Damage The letter came by FedEx. Inside: A formal notification that my tenured position as an economics professor had been eliminated—the second time in a matter of months my line had been retrenched, along with fifty colleagues and entire departments. The first had been noisy and public. The second…

Several pairs of hands joined together against a background of dark gray wood

Four Ways to Manage Ugly Stress Responses to Big Beautiful Bills

BY MYIA CLARISSE WILLIAMS AND VERNON C. LINDSAY One “big beautiful bill” has introduced ugly stress responses and expanded job duties among diverse higher education practitioners. Current provisions impose additional limits on Grad PLUS and Parent PLUS loans. Federal loan restrictions, the loss of DEI initiatives, and other meaningful programs that impact student retention also…

blackboard background shows the word FEAR in bright pink chalk crossed out with yellow chalk above the word COURAGE in green chalk, underlined with yellow chalk

How US Universities Can Survive State Terrorism

BY CATHERINE D’IGNAZIO As a professor at MIT, I find myself navigating strange waters these days. Last semester, I advised the thesis of a student who left the country because she did not feel welcome in the United States (and she is a citizen). I listened to exceptional students from around the world tell me…

View from the side of bronze "alma mater" statue at Columbia University, showing the allegorical figure of a woman wearing a laurel wreath on her head and flowing ropes and holding a scepter in her right hand

Government Intrusion at Columbia Has Only Just Begun

BY AARON NISENSON The Trump administration has successfully buried a key component of the Columbia settlement agreement. The focus on monetary damages paid by the university and restrictions on campus protests and diversity policies obscures the Trump administration’s imposition of the right to interfere directly in university admissions, hiring, and promotion decisions. The Trump administration…